Connect with us

News

18 year fight to build new home fails at the sixth attempt

Avatar photo

Published

on

To five refusals – dating back to 2005 – can now be added a sixth in failed bids to build a house on what a planning inspector described as an ‘irregularly shaped’ strip of land.

Stephen Isaacson had fingers firmly crossed when he applied in October 2021 for permission to build a two-bedroom detached home on the land he owns next to his 7 Northfield Road, Soham.

Consent was refused by East Cambridgeshire District Council and their decision has been confirmed following an appeal to the Government Planning Inspectorate.

The inspector, Mr G Norman, visited the site in February and has delivered his verdict.

He said the main issues were:

  • The effect of the development on the character and appearance of the area.
  • The effect of the development on the living conditions of nearby residents.
  • The effect of the development on highway safety.
  • Whether suitable biodiversity net gain has been demonstrated.

“The appeal site currently forms a visible and spacious gap within the immediate street scene, breaking up the built form,” he said.

“However, I do not find that gaps between dwellings form a consistent or characteristic pattern of development along this part of Northfield Road.

East Cambs planners argued that the proposed new home on this site in Soham would result in “a cramped and contrived development on a plot less than 300sqm”. The Planning Inspectorate has confirmed their refusal.

East Cambs planners argued that the proposed new home on this site in Soham would result in “a cramped and contrived development on a plot less than 300sqm”. The Planning Inspectorate has confirmed their refusal.

“As such, the development of the appeal site would not be harmful to the overall pattern of development in respect of open gaps in this case.”

He added: “However, the appeal site is irregularly shaped and the introduction of a detached dwelling into this site would appear cramped and out of character with the more generous plots in the immediate surroundings due to the size of the site and the positioning of the proposed dwelling. “

Mr Norman explained that the district council’s design guide states that, in most cases, building plots should be approximately 300 square metres “and this site falls below this size.

“Furthermore, along this side of Northfield Road, the dwellings are predominantly semi-detached, and the introduction of the detached dwelling would disrupt the regular form of the immediate street scene.”

Other sites not comparable says inspector

The inspector said he had regard to other sites where homes have been extended or new properties built.

“I have limited details of the consideration behind these examples, and I do not consider that extensions to dwellings are comparable to the proposal before me,” he said.

“In addition, these examples are in different locations, some at a distance from the appeal site, where the context of the surroundings are different.

“As such, I find that these examples are not sufficient to justify the proposed development in this instance.”

Mr Norman concluded: “For the above reasons, I conclude that the proposed development would be at odds with, and harmful to, the character and appearance of the surrounding area.”

As such it failed to comply with council policies.

East Cambs planners argued that the proposed new home on this site in Soham would result in “a cramped and contrived development on a plot less than 300sqm”. The Planning Inspectorate has confirmed their refusal.

East Cambs planners argued that the proposed new home on this site in Soham would result in “a cramped and contrived development on a plot less than 300sqm”. The Planning Inspectorate has confirmed their refusal.

“Collectively these seek to ensure that development provide complementary relationships with the existing development and relate sympathetically to the surrounding area, amongst other things,” he said.

He agreed there would be no overlooking of neighbours or loss of privacy, and in many respects complied with highways requirements but he was concerned about biodiversity.

East Cambs Council require development to protect the biodiversity value of land, minimise harm to or loss of environmental features and habitats and conserve and incorporate biodiversity features, amongst other things.

And the council now has a natural environment supplementary document.

“This requires all development proposals to contribute and enhance the natural and local environment by firstly avoiding impacts where possible, minimising impacts on biodiversity and providing measurable net gains for biodiversity amongst other things,” he said.

“The appeal site currently comprises an area of grass with a strip of concrete pathway, with trees and hedging on the adjacent site.

“I note that the council have not specified that there are currently any important trees or landscaping features within the site.

“However, the policies require demonstrable biodiversity net gain and evidence that the development would conserve and where possible enhance landscape and biodiversity features and whilst this may be achievable through a careful landscaping scheme or other means, I have been provided with insufficient evidence at this stage to demonstrate that this could be achieved.”

The proposals failed to show how they “relate to the need to protect and enhance biodiversity features and demonstrate a significance biodiversity net gain”.

Mr Norman said felt that the positive nature of a new home weighed against “the harm identified” and the fact the proposal is contrary to a number of council policies, led him to “conclude that the appeal should be dismissed”.

No reason to refuse say agents

Agents for Mr Isaacson had argued that the site is not located in a Green Belt, a Conservation Area, an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty, a Green Wedge” or any other area designated locally which would restrict or prevent appropriate efficient development.

“All main services are already present.

“Post and newspapers are delivered to all of the houses in the immediate area of the site and refuse bins and recycle bins are emptied on a regular basis.

“The development will have no adverse impact on existing services.”

The agents added: “Small sites can make an important contribution to housing requirements in this area and are often built out quickly. The housing demand for this size of property on a non-estate location is exceptionally strong in Soham.”

In their refusal, East Cambs Council said the proposed new home had not overcome the previous reason for refusal.

“It still results in the loss of a spacious gap between two pairs of semi-detached dwellings, breaking up the rhythm of the existing street scene and disrupting the pattern of important open spaces between each pair of semi-detached dwellings,” said council planners.

“It also still results in a cramped and contrived development on a plot less than 300sqm.

“It is therefore considered that the proposed development would create a significant detrimental impact upon the character and appearance of the area.”

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Facebook

Read More

Karolis Tauckela, 27, was arrested in the early hours of Wednesday morning (19 June) by road policing officers. Karolis Tauckela, 27, was arrested in the early hours of Wednesday morning (19 June) by road policing officers.
News2 hours ago

Man charged after £600,000 car thefts in Crowland, Spalding, Whittlesey, Pinchbeck, Harston, Melton Mowbray

Accused bailed but tagged and passport confiscated

March for Free Palestine Peterborough. The march left Lincoln Road Park and ended at Cathedral Square where speakers addressed the public. Lincoln Road / Cathedral Square, Peterborough Sunday 23 June 2024. Picture by Terry Harris. March for Free Palestine Peterborough. The march left Lincoln Road Park and ended at Cathedral Square where speakers addressed the public. Lincoln Road / Cathedral Square, Peterborough Sunday 23 June 2024. Picture by Terry Harris.
News3 hours ago

GALLERY: Hundreds turn out for Peterborough March for a Free Palestine

Peterborough branch of Palestine Solidarity Campaign

Hustings chair Amir Suleman was described in pre hustings publicity as “accomplished presenter and host since 2008. He is a freelance presenter with BBC Radio Cambridgeshire and also a volunteer radio presenter with Salaam Radio in Peterborough since 2016”. Hustings chair Amir Suleman was described in pre hustings publicity as “accomplished presenter and host since 2008. He is a freelance presenter with BBC Radio Cambridgeshire and also a volunteer radio presenter with Salaam Radio in Peterborough since 2016”.
News2 days ago

Media banned from Peterborough hustings event chaired by BBC Radio Cambridgeshire presenter

Advance publicity stated it was a 'public' meeting

Flashback to beginning of May when Mr Browne reported that over 570 people had shared concerns and comments about Longsands and Ernulf over the previous month. He is pictured with schools minister Damian Hinds discussing the concerns. Flashback to beginning of May when Mr Browne reported that over 570 people had shared concerns and comments about Longsands and Ernulf over the previous month. He is pictured with schools minister Damian Hinds discussing the concerns.
News2 days ago

OPINION: There is clearly something deeply dysfunctional going on to drive teachers to leave in such high numbers

'The head at Ernulf has resigned -27 teachers to leave Longsands'

Matt Howard (left) head of insolvency and recovery at Price Bailey and (right) Stuart Morton, a Price Bailey partner and insolvency practitioner. Centre is Simon Somerville-Large, founder and sole director of Laragh House Developments Ltd. Matt Howard (left) head of insolvency and recovery at Price Bailey and (right) Stuart Morton, a Price Bailey partner and insolvency practitioner. Centre is Simon Somerville-Large, founder and sole director of Laragh House Developments Ltd.
News2 days ago

Joint insolvency practitioners appointed to Laragh House Developments Ltd

A CVL is an insolvent liquidation process initiated by shareholders or directors

Ely taxi driver Jerzy Masjanis has had his joint hackney carriage and private hire driver licence revoked Ely taxi driver Jerzy Masjanis has had his joint hackney carriage and private hire driver licence revoked
News3 days ago

Rude taxi driver who also nearly ran over woman and her dog has licence revoked

Ely taxi driver 'demonstrated a history of non-compliance'

Swimmers take to the pool at 4am for a sunrise swim on the Summer Solstice. City lido, Peterborough Thursday 20 June 2024. Picture by Terry Harris. Swimmers take to the pool at 4am for a sunrise swim on the Summer Solstice. City lido, Peterborough Thursday 20 June 2024. Picture by Terry Harris.
News4 days ago

WATCH: ‘Hooray an’ up she rises, early in the morning’ for summer solstice Peterborough swim

Lido promises 'a truly magical experience'

A 53-year-old motorcyclist from Peterborough died in a crash at Papworth Everard A 53-year-old motorcyclist from Peterborough died in a crash at Papworth Everard
News4 days ago

Peterborough death crash victim Paul Istead ‘a special kinda guy’ says best friend

'RIP my friend. We miss you already and so much'

Line Diagram of Wisbech Branch (Quail Map Company, 1998) Line Diagram of Wisbech Branch (Quail Map Company, 1998)
News4 days ago

OPINION: Let’s build a new station at Wisbech and then dare the railway not to come

A station without any trains — how utterly stupid! But is it?

Akshata Murty took along Lucia Hunt, wife of the Chancellor, Jeremy Hunt, and Susie Cleverly, wife of the Home Secretary, James Cleverly to support Lucy Frazer Akshata Murty took along Lucia Hunt, wife of the Chancellor, Jeremy Hunt, and Susie Cleverly, wife of the Home Secretary, James Cleverly to support Lucy Frazer
News5 days ago

GALLERY: ‘Westminster Wives’ including Mrs Sunak fight to save Lucy Frazer

A formidable trio of political wives turned out to support Lucy Frazer.