Connect with us

News

‘Bullying, toxic culture’ nearly killed me says Peterborough city councillor

Avatar photo

Published

on

A Peterborough councillor – cleared of allegedly plotting against council leader Wayne Fitzgerald – has spoken of a ‘bullying, toxic’ culture within the ruling group that he says nearly killed him.

Cllr Mohammed Farooq, president of the NW Conservative Association, was re-instated but then quit the Conservative group on Peterborough City Council.

He was invited back into the Tory fold two days ago (Monday June 5th) at the Conservative group meeting after there was found to be no evidence to support these allegations.

Advertisements
Pictures
Advertisement

Tory resignations, suspension, mayhem, and madness at Peterborough

“I’ve been in a toxic atmosphere been victimized, been bullied and the suspension over the last three weeks has been the final straw,” he said in an exclusive interview with respected Peterborough journalist Paul Stainton for CambsNews.

“It has almost killed me.”

Advertisement

His explosive interview, recorded yesterday and released today, means another resignation – and an even more troublesome headache – for Peterborough City Council leader Wayne Fitzgerald.

“I've been in a toxic atmosphere been victimized, been bullied and the suspension over the last three weeks has been the final straw,” said Cllr Mohammed Farooq. “It has almost killed me.” PHOTO: Terry Harris

“I’ve been in a toxic atmosphere been victimized, been bullied and the suspension over the last three weeks has been the final straw,” said Cllr Mohammed Farooq. “It has almost killed me.” PHOTO: Terry Harris

Cllr Farooq, a successful businessman and councillor for Hargate and Hempsted since 2018, described the moment he receive notice of his suspension.

“On the Saturday when I received this fabricated piece of paper, I had chest pains.

Advertisement

“I had a heart attack would you believe because of that fabricated piece of paper which alleges something which I did not do, and I thought that was the final straw.

 

Advertisement

“The bullying text messages what I’ve gone through has been an unbelievable burden and unbelievable stress for me, my family and particularly for my health

“I’m a colitis patient and that has all flared up and I have today said ‘look enough is enough’ and this suspension over the last three weeks was the final straw.”

In the interview, conducted by Paul Stainton, Cllr Farooq was asked about the reason for the suspension.

“That’s the bizarre thing,” said Cllr Farooq.

Advertisement

‘Kangaroo court found no evidence’ 

“I was accused of working with other councillors to bring a no-confidence vote in in the leader Wayne Fitzgerald

“Well under no circumstances I did that, and they did this investigation, this kangaroo court, and they found no evidence and I’ve been exonerated for that.

“But you know what that is only until the next moment, and I don’t want to live that moment.”

Advertisement

He said that while others were “spending their time victimizing me the citizens of Peterborough get missed out.

“I've been in a toxic atmosphere been victimized, been bullied and the suspension over the last three weeks has been the final straw,” said Cllr Mohammed Farooq. “It has almost killed me.” PHOTO: Terry Harris

“I’ve been in a toxic atmosphere been victimized, been bullied and the suspension over the last three weeks has been the final straw,” said Cllr Mohammed Farooq. “It has almost killed me.” PHOTO: Terry Harris

“I want to emphasize all my work, my time working for my ward residents working for the overall city of Peterborough and I want them to do the same thing and if they’re distracted by trying to destroy me or feel threatened by me then I’d remove myself.”

Quizzed about a possible “culture of fear at the heart of politics in Peterborough”, and allegations of bullying, Cllr Farooq was asked about any proof of that he might have.

Advertisement

Tories rocked by second resignation of the day – and its only 9 o’clock

Although he retains a large number of WhatsApp messages that he says supports his claims, “I wouldn’t like to go individually to that, I wouldn’t like to talk ill about anybody who I’m walking away from; it’s just not right

“However as far as you mentioned about the proof that report is a damning proof which gave me a heart attack

Advertisement

‘You are a poison’ claim

“Some of the text messages calls me ‘you are a poison’- that is horrendous.”

He added: “I don’t condone that in any work practice particularly in the public sector particularly in a council environment where our role is voluntary.

VIDEO: Council leader emphatic ‘nobody can buy planning permission’

Advertisement

“We’re not there for money; nobody’s there for money, for five six hundred pound a month or seven eight hundred or whatever it is.

“We are there to help the people of Peterborough and bring the best to our city

“And if that experience is very unpleasant for us, then for me it’s not right for me to be in that part of that.”

Advertisement

He added: “The bigger impact is that we are preventing the good talented people coming into the council by having that kind of toxic culture in the city council.”

“I've been in a toxic atmosphere been victimized, been bullied and the suspension over the last three weeks has been the final straw,” said Cllr Mohammed Farooq. “It has almost killed me.” PHOTO: Terry Harris

“I’ve been in a toxic atmosphere been victimized, been bullied and the suspension over the last three weeks has been the final straw,” said Cllr Mohammed Farooq. “It has almost killed me.” PHOTO: Terry Harris

Asked how he was feeling now, he replied: “Well, you know wounds heal very slowly; it’ll take time.

“I am going to spend some time sort of on a back seat

Advertisement
Advertisements
canopyuk.com in-article

“I’ll continue to work hard for my ward, but I still look forward to carrying on in the council and delivering best to my ability for Hargate and Hempsted ward and for the wider community of Peterborough.”

Third – and biggest – name quits Tory group on Peterborough Council

Cllr Farooq said he was not short of support during his period of suspension, but it came from an unexpected quarter.

Advertisement

“Amazingly I had a lot of phone calls from the opposition party members.

“But there were still a few number of my own group who rang me but not many, sadly not many; and that’s something for them to tell me what it was but last night it’s that is for them to tell me.”

He began the interview by explaining that “it is with extreme heavy heart after spending five six years with the Conservative Party, working with MP Shailesh Vara, working with Northwest Cambridgeshire Conservative Association (I am the president of the association) I am leaving the Conservative group after having very difficult two last years.

“I was accused of working with other councillors to bring a no-confidence vote in in the leader Wayne Fitzgerald (above) “Well under no circumstances I did that, and they did this investigation, this kangaroo court, and they found no evidence and I've been exonerated for that.

“I was accused of working with other councillors to bring a no-confidence vote in in the leader Wayne Fitzgerald (above) “Well under no circumstances I did that, and they did this investigation, this kangaroo court, and they found no evidence and I’ve been exonerated for that.
Picture by Terry Harris.

Advertisement

“I will continue to serve my Hargate and Hempsted ward where I have been an active member of the community for the past 25 years, five of them as local councillor.”

He added: “I am saddened and disappointed to leave the Conservative group in such circumstances, after five years.

“I’m hoping to continue to do that to best of my ability.

“However, I’ve come to this very difficult decision because the last two years have been hell for me.

Advertisement

“Prior to that the first three years I immensely enjoyed as part of the cabinet for John Holdich.

“I was one of the key people who brought Aragon direct services in-house; I brought the I.T services in-house saving millions of pounds for the council and first and foremost delivering value for money for our taxpayers.

Past 2 years ‘very very difficult for me’

“I am a businessman, and this is what I do; delivering value for money and introducing efficiencies but last two years have been very very difficult for me.”

Advertisement

Cllr Farooq was asked if other members of the Conservative group on Peterborough City Council were afraid to speak out.

“I don’t know I’m not I’m not going to speak on their behalf.”

Looking forward, he said he had “walked away” to protect his health and well-being.

But, he said, the city council “most importantly” needed to deal with issues that were holding it back.

Advertisement

“We need to remove these distractions,” he said. “That’s one of the reasons I’ve removed myself, so the citizens gets the full concentration of the of the leadership and after council”

But he said “about how we get rid of it I don’t know yet; I haven’t looked at it and I don’t know yet.

“I am too ill to worry about that, so I’ve just removed myself from that process”.

MP Shailish Vara said: “The government has made clear that the presumption for rural primary schools is that they should stay open.”

Cllr Farooq began the interview by explaining that “it is with extreme heavy heart after spending five six years with the Conservative Party, working with MP Shailesh Vara (above), working with Northwest Cambridgeshire Conservative Association (I am the president of the association) I am leaving the Conservative group after having very difficult two last years.

Advertisement

Of how to restore trust and decency, he said: “I don’t have the magic pill for that right now.”

He said change could mean the “the city could be worse off, or the city could be considerably better off. But that’s something for all the councillors to work together all the councillors collaboratively work together

“And I’m sorry that word is being used a lot and it has lost its value in the process, but they could work together better and remove the toxic side of it.”

Where now for councillor?

Advertisement

Would he become an independent councillor or move to another group after what had happened to him?

“For now, I’m removing myself from harm’s length,” he added.

The main opposition party whip said no member of her group has spoken to any Conservative member regarding a motion or vote of no confidence against Wayne Fitzgerald.

Cllr Dr Shabina Qayyum, whip for the city council Labour group, said: “As chief whip of the Labour group I can also validate that the group has had no discussion or action on their agenda regarding a confidence vote against the leader.”

Advertisement
“I've been in a toxic atmosphere been victimized, been bullied and the suspension over the last three weeks has been the final straw,” said Cllr Farooq in an exclusive interview with respected Peterborough journalist Paul Stainton for CambsNews. “It has almost killed me.” PHOTO: Terry Harris

“I’ve been in a toxic atmosphere been victimized, been bullied and the suspension over the last three weeks has been the final straw,” said Cllr Farooq in an exclusive interview with respected Peterborough journalist Paul Stainton for CambsNews. “It has almost killed me.” PHOTO: Terry Harris

Farooq suffers from Colitis/Crohn’s, a long-term condition of the bowel of which stress is a key aggravating factor.

He says the poisonous atmosphere in the Tory group and the constant character assassination and bullying he has endured, have contributed to his worsening health issues, and his decision to leave the group.

But on an optimistic note, he added: “I hope to make similar, if not more contributions to the council away from this stressful atmosphere.

Advertisement

“I wish my former colleagues on the Conservative group the best of luck.”

 

Facebook

Read More

The bodies of John and Barbara Nicholls were recovered from the 20ft river at March. Police confirmed there were no suspicious circumstances; their inquests opened yesterday. PHOTO: Terry Harris for CambsNews The bodies of John and Barbara Nicholls were recovered from the 20ft river at March. Police confirmed there were no suspicious circumstances; their inquests opened yesterday. PHOTO: Terry Harris for CambsNews
News3 hours ago

Inquests open into deaths of Friday Bridge couple pulled from Fenland river

Cause of death has not been established as yet

Wounded gull being cared for by RSPCA at East Winch Wildlife Hospital near King’s Lynn (right) with X-ray of injuries. Image: RSPCA Wounded gull being cared for by RSPCA at East Winch Wildlife Hospital near King’s Lynn (right) with X-ray of injuries. Image: RSPCA
News4 hours ago

Gull shot and wounded fights for life after Wisbech air gun attack

Wild birds are protected under the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981

“At 8.25pm on Thursday (25) a crew from Ely was called to a car fire on Second Drove in Queen Adelaide,” said a spokesperson for Cambridgeshire fire and rescue. PHOTO: CambsNews reader “At 8.25pm on Thursday (25) a crew from Ely was called to a car fire on Second Drove in Queen Adelaide,” said a spokesperson for Cambridgeshire fire and rescue. PHOTO: CambsNews reader
News8 hours ago

Firefighters attend blazing car near Ely – luckily, the driver got out in time

Car caught fire in Second Drove, Queen Adelaide

From Monday (29 July), the A1307 there will be one lane closed in both directions for the works – it will involve getting soil samples, stripping back the vegetation, and clearing out the drains. From Monday (29 July), the A1307 there will be one lane closed in both directions for the works – it will involve getting soil samples, stripping back the vegetation, and clearing out the drains.
News9 hours ago

A1307 – in ‘old money’ the former A14 – to get long awaited make over

From Monday (29 July), there will be one lane closed in both directions

California commerce chiefs visit to Marshall Cambridge will ‘deepen local ties’ Marshall hosted representatives from North Carolina’s Department of Commerce and economic development partnerships for a tour of its Cambridge headquarters this week “providing a glimpse of the capabilities, heritage and values it will soon be bringing to the state”. A Marshall spokesperson said: “As progress continues on the construction of the company’s new maintenance, repair, overhaul (MRO) and engineering facility at Piedmont Triad International Airport, the visit served to deepen local ties while demonstrating the value Marshall’s presence promises to bring to North Carolina.” The tour covered a range of Marshall’s aerospace operations, including MRO work on the United States Marine Corps fleet of KC-130J airlifters, and heavy engineering projects such as the removal and replacement of aircraft centre wing boxes. “It was incredibly rewarding to showcase our capabilities on home turf to some of the individuals whose support and enthusiasm made it so easy to choose North Carolina as a home for our new U.S. facility,” said Marshall MRO Support Services Director Chris Dare. “Our Cambridge and Greensboro operations may be thousands expertise, apart, but they will share a common commitment to providing mission-critical support for our customers, and I am certain the MRO technical knowledge, expertise and capabilities we have cultivated in the UK will grow and flourish in North Carolina’s thriving aerospace ecosystem.” In addition to Secretary of Commerce Machelle Baker Sanders, the delegation included Christopher Chung, CEO of the Economic Development Partnership of North Carolina, and Brent Christensen, President, and CEO of Greensboro Chamber of Commerce. “This visit yielded a deep understanding of the high-value work Marshall is delivering for the U.S. Marine Corps and more than a dozen other customers around the world,” said Sanders. “As the new facility comes ever-closer to opening its doors, Marshall is a perfect example of how the burgeoning UK-North Carolina relationship will continue to foster skilled employment and economic activity for our state.” Earlier this week, members of Marshall’s senior leadership team also met with the North Carolina delegation at a series of events facilitated by the UK’s Department of Business and Trade during the Farnborough International Airshow. These engagements charted two years of progress since the July 2022 signing of a landmark economic arrangement between North Carolina and the UK to strengthen economic ties and transition to a clean energy economy. Earlier this month, CNBC ranked North Carolina among the top three states to do business in the U.S. for the fifth year running. Visit to Marshall’s Cambridge by representatives of North Carolina’s Department of Commerce and economic development partnerships. The visit was led by Secretary of Commerce Machelle Baker Sanders, Economic Development Partnership of North Carolina CEO Christopher Chung, and Greensboro Chamber of Commerce President Brent Christensen – in addition to senior and support staff from all three organisations. California commerce chiefs visit to Marshall Cambridge will ‘deepen local ties’ Marshall hosted representatives from North Carolina’s Department of Commerce and economic development partnerships for a tour of its Cambridge headquarters this week “providing a glimpse of the capabilities, heritage and values it will soon be bringing to the state”. A Marshall spokesperson said: “As progress continues on the construction of the company’s new maintenance, repair, overhaul (MRO) and engineering facility at Piedmont Triad International Airport, the visit served to deepen local ties while demonstrating the value Marshall’s presence promises to bring to North Carolina.” The tour covered a range of Marshall’s aerospace operations, including MRO work on the United States Marine Corps fleet of KC-130J airlifters, and heavy engineering projects such as the removal and replacement of aircraft centre wing boxes. “It was incredibly rewarding to showcase our capabilities on home turf to some of the individuals whose support and enthusiasm made it so easy to choose North Carolina as a home for our new U.S. facility,” said Marshall MRO Support Services Director Chris Dare. “Our Cambridge and Greensboro operations may be thousands expertise, apart, but they will share a common commitment to providing mission-critical support for our customers, and I am certain the MRO technical knowledge, expertise and capabilities we have cultivated in the UK will grow and flourish in North Carolina’s thriving aerospace ecosystem.” In addition to Secretary of Commerce Machelle Baker Sanders, the delegation included Christopher Chung, CEO of the Economic Development Partnership of North Carolina, and Brent Christensen, President, and CEO of Greensboro Chamber of Commerce. “This visit yielded a deep understanding of the high-value work Marshall is delivering for the U.S. Marine Corps and more than a dozen other customers around the world,” said Sanders. “As the new facility comes ever-closer to opening its doors, Marshall is a perfect example of how the burgeoning UK-North Carolina relationship will continue to foster skilled employment and economic activity for our state.” Earlier this week, members of Marshall’s senior leadership team also met with the North Carolina delegation at a series of events facilitated by the UK’s Department of Business and Trade during the Farnborough International Airshow. These engagements charted two years of progress since the July 2022 signing of a landmark economic arrangement between North Carolina and the UK to strengthen economic ties and transition to a clean energy economy. Earlier this month, CNBC ranked North Carolina among the top three states to do business in the U.S. for the fifth year running. Visit to Marshall’s Cambridge by representatives of North Carolina’s Department of Commerce and economic development partnerships. The visit was led by Secretary of Commerce Machelle Baker Sanders, Economic Development Partnership of North Carolina CEO Christopher Chung, and Greensboro Chamber of Commerce President Brent Christensen – in addition to senior and support staff from all three organisations. Visit to Marshall’s Cambridge by representatives of North Carolina’s Department of Commerce and economic development partnerships. The visit was led by Secretary of Commerce Machelle Baker Sanders, Economic Development Partnership of North Carolina CEO Christopher Chung, and Greensboro Chamber of Commerce President Brent Christensen – in addition to senior and support staff from all three organisations. California commerce chiefs visit to Marshall Cambridge will ‘deepen local ties’ Marshall hosted representatives from North Carolina’s Department of Commerce and economic development partnerships for a tour of its Cambridge headquarters this week “providing a glimpse of the capabilities, heritage and values it will soon be bringing to the state”. A Marshall spokesperson said: “As progress continues on the construction of the company’s new maintenance, repair, overhaul (MRO) and engineering facility at Piedmont Triad International Airport, the visit served to deepen local ties while demonstrating the value Marshall’s presence promises to bring to North Carolina.” The tour covered a range of Marshall’s aerospace operations, including MRO work on the United States Marine Corps fleet of KC-130J airlifters, and heavy engineering projects such as the removal and replacement of aircraft centre wing boxes. “It was incredibly rewarding to showcase our capabilities on home turf to some of the individuals whose support and enthusiasm made it so easy to choose North Carolina as a home for our new U.S. facility,” said Marshall MRO Support Services Director Chris Dare. “Our Cambridge and Greensboro operations may be thousands expertise, apart, but they will share a common commitment to providing mission-critical support for our customers, and I am certain the MRO technical knowledge, expertise and capabilities we have cultivated in the UK will grow and flourish in North Carolina’s thriving aerospace ecosystem.” In addition to Secretary of Commerce Machelle Baker Sanders, the delegation included Christopher Chung, CEO of the Economic Development Partnership of North Carolina, and Brent Christensen, President, and CEO of Greensboro Chamber of Commerce. “This visit yielded a deep understanding of the high-value work Marshall is delivering for the U.S. Marine Corps and more than a dozen other customers around the world,” said Sanders. “As the new facility comes ever-closer to opening its doors, Marshall is a perfect example of how the burgeoning UK-North Carolina relationship will continue to foster skilled employment and economic activity for our state.” Earlier this week, members of Marshall’s senior leadership team also met with the North Carolina delegation at a series of events facilitated by the UK’s Department of Business and Trade during the Farnborough International Airshow. These engagements charted two years of progress since the July 2022 signing of a landmark economic arrangement between North Carolina and the UK to strengthen economic ties and transition to a clean energy economy. Earlier this month, CNBC ranked North Carolina among the top three states to do business in the U.S. for the fifth year running. Visit to Marshall’s Cambridge by representatives of North Carolina’s Department of Commerce and economic development partnerships. The visit was led by Secretary of Commerce Machelle Baker Sanders, Economic Development Partnership of North Carolina CEO Christopher Chung, and Greensboro Chamber of Commerce President Brent Christensen – in addition to senior and support staff from all three organisations. California commerce chiefs visit to Marshall Cambridge will ‘deepen local ties’ Marshall hosted representatives from North Carolina’s Department of Commerce and economic development partnerships for a tour of its Cambridge headquarters this week “providing a glimpse of the capabilities, heritage and values it will soon be bringing to the state”. A Marshall spokesperson said: “As progress continues on the construction of the company’s new maintenance, repair, overhaul (MRO) and engineering facility at Piedmont Triad International Airport, the visit served to deepen local ties while demonstrating the value Marshall’s presence promises to bring to North Carolina.” The tour covered a range of Marshall’s aerospace operations, including MRO work on the United States Marine Corps fleet of KC-130J airlifters, and heavy engineering projects such as the removal and replacement of aircraft centre wing boxes. “It was incredibly rewarding to showcase our capabilities on home turf to some of the individuals whose support and enthusiasm made it so easy to choose North Carolina as a home for our new U.S. facility,” said Marshall MRO Support Services Director Chris Dare. “Our Cambridge and Greensboro operations may be thousands expertise, apart, but they will share a common commitment to providing mission-critical support for our customers, and I am certain the MRO technical knowledge, expertise and capabilities we have cultivated in the UK will grow and flourish in North Carolina’s thriving aerospace ecosystem.” In addition to Secretary of Commerce Machelle Baker Sanders, the delegation included Christopher Chung, CEO of the Economic Development Partnership of North Carolina, and Brent Christensen, President, and CEO of Greensboro Chamber of Commerce. “This visit yielded a deep understanding of the high-value work Marshall is delivering for the U.S. Marine Corps and more than a dozen other customers around the world,” said Sanders. “As the new facility comes ever-closer to opening its doors, Marshall is a perfect example of how the burgeoning UK-North Carolina relationship will continue to foster skilled employment and economic activity for our state.” Earlier this week, members of Marshall’s senior leadership team also met with the North Carolina delegation at a series of events facilitated by the UK’s Department of Business and Trade during the Farnborough International Airshow. These engagements charted two years of progress since the July 2022 signing of a landmark economic arrangement between North Carolina and the UK to strengthen economic ties and transition to a clean energy economy. Earlier this month, CNBC ranked North Carolina among the top three states to do business in the U.S. for the fifth year running. Visit to Marshall’s Cambridge by representatives of North Carolina’s Department of Commerce and economic development partnerships. The visit was led by Secretary of Commerce Machelle Baker Sanders, Economic Development Partnership of North Carolina CEO Christopher Chung, and Greensboro Chamber of Commerce President Brent Christensen – in addition to senior and support staff from all three organisations. Visit to Marshall’s Cambridge by representatives of North Carolina’s Department of Commerce and economic development partnerships. The visit was led by Secretary of Commerce Machelle Baker Sanders, Economic Development Partnership of North Carolina CEO Christopher Chung, and Greensboro Chamber of Commerce President Brent Christensen – in addition to senior and support staff from all three organisations.
News9 hours ago

California commerce chiefs visit to Marshall of Cambridge will ‘deepen local ties’

The tour covered a range of Marshall’s aerospace operations

Wayne McKie, 46, forced open a ground-floor window of a house in Winchester Way, Thorpe Meadows, Peterborough. Wayne McKie, 46, forced open a ground-floor window of a house in Winchester Way, Thorpe Meadows, Peterborough.
News10 hours ago

WATCH: CCTV catches burglar who left family in ‘emotional turmoil’

'The effect McKie’s actions have had on the victims cannot be underestimated'

Community leaders have been celebrating better and safer journeys for people travelling in and around Mitcham’s Corner. Community leaders have been celebrating better and safer journeys for people travelling in and around Mitcham’s Corner.
News10 hours ago

Mitcham’s Corner, Cambridge now ‘safer and easier for people to walk and cycle’

Upgrades part of GCP’s Milton Road project

Stalker Graeme Clark, 43, of Willow Green, Needingworth, St Ives, who gave his victim £10,000 in a bid to make her stay in contact with him has been jailed. Stalker Graeme Clark, 43, of Willow Green, Needingworth, St Ives, who gave his victim £10,000 in a bid to make her stay in contact with him has been jailed.
News1 day ago

Obsessed Cambridgeshire stalker left victim ‘feeling in genuine fear’

Stalker messaged victim’s family and friends to 'check on her welfare'

Motorists who throw cigarette butts out of car windows are being warned to stop littering after two people were fined £400 each. Motorists who throw cigarette butts out of car windows are being warned to stop littering after two people were fined £400 each.
News1 day ago

Motorists fined £400 for tossing cigarette butts onto Cambridgeshire roads

South Cambs council invites public to report offenders

Councillor visit to ESCC (L-R: Councillor Geoffrey Seef, County Councillor for St Neots The Eatons [local councillor]; Rob Ashwell, chairman of ESCC; Cllr Alex Bulat Vice-Chair of Cambridgeshire County Council's Communities, Social Mobility, and Inclusion Committee). Credit to Cambridgeshire County Council. Councillor visit to ESCC (L-R: Councillor Geoffrey Seef, County Councillor for St Neots The Eatons [local councillor]; Rob Ashwell, chairman of ESCC; Cllr Alex Bulat Vice-Chair of Cambridgeshire County Council's Communities, Social Mobility, and Inclusion Committee). Credit to Cambridgeshire County Council.
News1 day ago

Cricket club’s ‘one small step for man, one giant leap for mankind’ towards net zero

Eaton Socon Cricket Club had seen their energy costs triple