Connect with us

News

East Cambs Council loses fight to stop 10 holiday lodges at caravan park

“Additional holiday accommodation here could have benefits for local businesses and help support local services in Littleport”.

Avatar photo

Published

on

A caravan park in the Fens has won its battle with East Cambridgeshire District Council to expand by providing 10 holiday lodges.

Riverside Park, New River Bank, Littleport, successfully appealed to the Planning Inspectorate after the council refused them permission.

The inspector who granted consent said the main issues raised were whether the proposal was justified and the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the area.

Advertisements
Pictures

He said the lodges would make use of part of a field to the side of the caravan site, which was formerly used for growing potatoes but has since been subdivided.

Advertisements
Sellebrity Soccer

The inspector said the area “is an attractive destination for overnight stays” and there was a general need for additional tourist accommodation, particularly within the hotel, caravan, and camping sectors.

Planning policies support proposals for new or extended caravan-lodge sites, subject to a number of criteria, said the inspector.

“Amongst other considerations, the policy requires that the need for the additional accommodation can be justified, and that there is no significant adverse effect on the character and appearance of the area,” he felt.

Riverside Park, New River Bank, Littleport, successfully appealed to the Planning Inspectorate after the council refused them permission for 10 holiday lodges.

Riverside Park, New River Bank, Littleport, successfully appealed to the Planning Inspectorate after the council refused them permission for 10 holiday lodges.

He said the site is within easy reach of Littleport, the river and local footpaths, “so occupiers of the proposed accommodation would be able to make use of local facilities, and easily explore the surrounding rural landscape.

“Additional holiday accommodation here could have benefits for local businesses and help support local services in Littleport”.

He said a ‘needs and benefits report” suggested nearby sites had a relatively small number of static caravan/lodge type accommodation.

“Owing to commercial sensitivities, the information provided by other sites was limited, but the responses received suggest that there is a steady and increasing demand for the type of accommodation proposed, with some nearby sites considering expanding their offer of holiday lodges,” he said.

“Taking into account the above considerations, I am satisfied that, in general terms, the need for additional holiday accommodation in this location can be justified, and the council has raised no concerns in this regard.

“However, there is disagreement as to whether the need for the additional accommodation can be justified in this particular case, given the existing site history.”

The inspector pointed out that Riverside Park was initially established as a site for touring caravans in the 1980s, but over time it has changed to what is now predominately a residential park home site.

The number of static caravans on the site has incrementally increased, and through a certificate of lawfulness of existing use their unrestricted, year-round occupation has been established.

He said the owners of the site had confirmed that, of the 49 units, just seven are currently used as holiday accommodation, with the remaining units in permanent residential use.

Riverside Park, New River Bank, Littleport, successfully appealed to the Planning Inspectorate after the council refused them permission for 10 holiday lodges.

Riverside Park, New River Bank, Littleport, successfully appealed to the Planning Inspectorate after the council refused them permission for 10 holiday lodges.

“This shift away from holiday use has raised concerns as to whether the proposed use would be viable,” he said.

However, he said the new owner Thomas Murphy – who took over in 2016 – had found there was already a considerable amount of residential use on the site, and that the earlier move to residential use may well have been facilitated within a planning permission context which was less restrictive in relation to holiday accommodation than would be imposed now.

Advertisements
canopyuk.com in-article

Demand for holiday accommodation

“The residential use of the existing site is now well established, but this does not necessarily indicate that there is no demand or justification for holiday accommodation here,” said the inspector.

“Indeed, the evidence provided in the needs and benefits report suggests that there is currently demand for holiday accommodation of the type proposed in this area, and that this demand is anticipated to continue into the future.

“The council has indicated that a number of the existing units are on the market. Sales information indicates that they are being marketed as park homes or mobile homes, rather than being targeted as holiday accommodation.

“However, as they are in private ownership, the site owner has limited control over their resale to other individuals, or their existing or future use.”

The proposed lodges would be owned by Riverside Park and would be rented out by them.

“In this way, this part of the site would be operated as a purely holiday business, rather than the units being sold privately, as has previously happened on the existing part of the site.,” he said.

“As such, the proposal would effectively represent a diversification of the existing business, in a location which is appropriate for tourist accommodation.”

He added: “The detailed design of the lodges has not been provided, but the appellant has stated that the buildings would be similar to those on the existing site.

“Given the surrounding context, with two caravan sites nearby, such buildings would not be an unexpected form of development here.

Effect on character and appearance of area ‘acceptable’

“In light of the above considerations, I conclude that the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the area would be acceptable.”

The inspector added: “The proposed development would involve the loss of a small area of former arable land, adjacent to the existing caravan park and agricultural yard.

“The proximity of neighbouring uses, including the road and residential properties, means that the site and adjacent fields are likely to be subject to noise and visual disturbance.

“The area has little potential to be used by foraging or roosting geese and swans, so any disturbance to these species resulting from the proposed development is likely to be minimal.”

The inspector said he had imposed a condition restricting use to of the proposed units to holiday accommodation only, and requiring a register of occupation to be maintained,” he said.

“This is necessary to ensure that the units are not used for permanent residential use, which would be unacceptable in this countryside location and would raise additional concerns in relation to flood risk.”

I have used wording contained in Local Plan Policy EMP9, which sets out the Council’s approach to He concluded: “I have found that the need for the proposed change of use can be justified, and the effect on the character and appearance of the area would be acceptable.

“The proposal complies with the development plan and the framework, and no other considerations outweigh this finding.”

 

 

Facebook

Read More

Cllr Stephen Ferguson says he has Labour Party members support for him to stand as an independent candidate for St Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire constituency Cllr Stephen Ferguson says he has Labour Party members support for him to stand as an independent candidate for St Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire constituency
News8 hours ago

Labour woes tempt Ferguson to stand as Independent candidate in St Neots

'I have some serious thinking to do' says Cllr Stephen Ferguson

Rt Hon Chloe Smith MP keynote speech to Eastern Powerhouse Conference in Cambridge today. Rt Hon Chloe Smith MP keynote speech to Eastern Powerhouse Conference in Cambridge today.
News13 hours ago

OPINION: Four things important in how the East and its people will succeed: Investment, Talent, Technology, Resilience.

The journey ahead for the Eastern Powerhouse, and the region we lead, is a demanding one

Cooking up a storm: Marianna Masters who has been selected by Labour as their Parliamentary candidate for St Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire Cooking up a storm: Marianna Masters who has been selected by Labour as their Parliamentary candidate for St Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire
News14 hours ago

Labour ‘fury’ as Huntingdonshire members excluded from election candidate choice

Labour choice for St Neots 'incredibly undemocratic'

James Palmer (left) opening today’s Eastern Powerhouse conference in Cambridge and (right) Mayor Dr Nik Johnson visiting Middle Level Commissioners ahead of a tour of the St German's pumping station. James Palmer (left) opening today’s Eastern Powerhouse conference in Cambridge and (right) Mayor Dr Nik Johnson visiting Middle Level Commissioners ahead of a tour of the St German's pumping station.
News16 hours ago

James Palmer and Nik Johnson show there is more to unite than divide them

Both believe Cambridgeshire has massive potential still to unlock for jobs and growth

Ashley Baker, 41, subjected his partner to a barrage of abuse and controlling behaviour, including making her call him during her lunchbreak from work every day and forbidding her from going to the canteen Ashley Baker, 41, subjected his partner to a barrage of abuse and controlling behaviour, including making her call him during her lunchbreak from work every day and forbidding her from going to the canteen
News2 days ago

Doddington control freak Ashley Baker jailed for 7-year abuse of his partner

He controlled all aspects of her everyday life

Robert Sullivan, Chief Executive of the Football Foundation, said: “The Football Foundation is working closely with our partners – the Premier League, The FA and Government – to transform the quality of grassroots facilities in England by delivering projects like this across the country. Robert Sullivan, Chief Executive of the Football Foundation, said: “The Football Foundation is working closely with our partners – the Premier League, The FA and Government – to transform the quality of grassroots facilities in England by delivering projects like this across the country.
News2 days ago

£1m grant will provide Stadia 3G pitch at Wisbech St Mary 

The new Fenland pitch will serve as a catalyst for growth

Cllr Marianna Masters, Parliamentary candidate for St Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire, pictured with London Mayor Sadiq Khan Cllr Marianna Masters, Parliamentary candidate for St Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire, pictured with London Mayor Sadiq Khan
News2 days ago

Lambeth councillor is Parliamentary candidate for St Neots and Mid Cambs

Labour's Marianna Masters is chair of the Fabian Women’s Network

MP and culture secretary Lucy Frazer in Saudi Arabia and tells hosts ‘we admire your young and vibrant people. We value your spirit of enterprise and ambition’ MP and culture secretary Lucy Frazer in Saudi Arabia and tells hosts ‘we admire your young and vibrant people. We value your spirit of enterprise and ambition’
News2 days ago

Lucy Frazer says UK poised to support Saudi Arabia ‘as you look to transform your economy’ 

Culture secretary Lucy Frazer in Saudi Arabia

Chief constable Nick Dean (left) who had previously commended disgraced police officer Mark Coteman (right) for bravery, resilience, and quick thinking’ Chief constable Nick Dean (left) who had previously commended disgraced police officer Mark Coteman (right) for bravery, resilience, and quick thinking’
News2 days ago

‘Hero to zero’ Cambs cop sacked 6 days before Crown Court sentencing on drugs and fraud charges

Since January 2022 there have been 15 misconduct hearings at Cambridgeshire Constabulary

The Kite Runner is at Cambridge Arts Theatre until Saturday, May 18 ‘an enormously powerful night at the theatre’ The Kite Runner is at Cambridge Arts Theatre until Saturday, May 18 ‘an enormously powerful night at the theatre’
News2 days ago

REVIEW: The Kite Runner ‘a searing story of love and betrayal in Afghanistan’

The Kite Runner is at Cambridge Arts Theatre until Saturday, May 18