Connect with us

News

Enforcement action against Andrews Coaches of Foxton quashed on appeal

Planning Inspectorate rules ‘the enforcement notice is invalid and will be quashed’

Avatar photo

Published

on

The Planning Inspectorate quashed an enforcement notice issued by South Cambridgeshire District Council against Andrews Coaches of Foxton near Cambridge. The enforcement notice was served in September 2021 alleging breaches of planning control.

But D Hartley, the inspector who conducted an appeal, has confirmed, two years later, that “the enforcement notice does not specify with sufficient clarity the alleged breach of planning control.

“It is not open to me to correct the error in accordance with my powers since injustice would be caused were I to do so”.

Mr Hartley added: “The enforcement notice is invalid and will be quashed.”

The coach firm is based at 22 Cambridge Road, Foxton, and the council had alleged a material change of use for part of the land which they claimed did not having planning permission for a coach depot including the parking and storage of coaches.

Advertisements
canopyuk.com in-article

Council wanted coaches removed from land

The council had wanted the removal of all coaches and all items associated with the coach depot and coach storage permanently from part of the land.

South Cambridgeshire District Council also alleged Andrews Coaches had created an area of hardstanding for use as a coach depot on the land.

But boss Andrew Miller appealed to the Planning Inspectorate and has been successful in having the enforcement notice lifted.

Enforcement action against Andrews Coaches of Foxton -begun by South Cambridgeshire District Council - has been quashed on appeal

Enforcement action against Andrews Coaches of Foxton -begun by South Cambridgeshire District Council – has been quashed on appeal

The council had also told him to remove all hardstanding from the area of land in dispute and reseed with grass.

He was given three months to comply, but that period was frozen pending the appeal.

Mr Hartley said there were two grounds for appeal, and he had dealt with them together because of an overlap of issues.

His ruling – published last week – examines all the issues raised by the council and deals with the legalities in depth.

He concludes that “there has not been a material change of use as alleged by the notice”.

Mr Hartley said: “It is theoretically possible that there has been a material change of use through intensification of the coach depot component, but I cannot consider whether that has occurred because there is not sufficient evidence before me.

“In this case, I cannot therefore correct the breach of planning control without causing injustice.

“Furthermore, a possible correction of the breach of planning control would cause injustice in so far that the case made by the appellant in respect of some of the grounds of appeal would likely have been very different.”

Not sufficient clarity claim

He added: “The notice also relates to a hardstanding. This appears to be enforced against in its own right. The notice states that the same ‘land hatched blue’ as the alleged material change of use includes unauthorised hardstanding.

“Given my findings relating to the alleged material change of use, I do not find that there is sufficient clarity in the notice in terms of the purpose for which the said hardstanding would be used.

“It is not, for example, clear whether the hardstanding has been used to facilitate a material change of use through intensification of the mixed use on the site.”

Mr Hartley added: “A consideration of the hardstanding area in isolation is not possible as I cannot be certain about the specifics of the use of such hardstanding given my conclusion relating to the alleged material change of use.

“In other words, the consideration of the hardstanding area needs to be considered alongside the use of such land and the breach of planning control is not accurate and so does not provide the certainty needed in this regard.

Breach of planning control not described

“Furthermore, it is not clear whether the hardstanding area has or has not facilitated a material change of the land through intensification. This is a matter that would need to be separately investigated by the council.

“In conclusion, the notice does not describe a breach of planning control that has occurred.

“There has either been no material change of use and no breach, or there has been a different breach which the notice could not be corrected to describe. The outcome is the same either way.

“Furthermore, and for the reasons outlined, I cannot proceed to consider the alleged hardstanding with sufficient clarity and certainty in terms of its use.

“Therefore, and, for these reasons, the appeals succeed.”

 

Can you help us?

While you’re here, we are asking, for the first time, for readers to support us financially by taking out a modest subscription.

£2, or £3 or even £5 will help us achieve our goals. It will mean the second year of CambsNews will be livelier, healthier, and much better placed to cover the important issues affecting our everyday lives.

Your subscription simply means we can provide and expand our news FREE to all readers (Read More)

Will you help us? Simply click the link below to make a donation.

Facebook

Read More

Firefighters stage protest in Huntingdon over reduction in reduction to fire crews PHOTO: Mark Thomas Firefighters stage protest in Huntingdon over reduction in reduction to fire crews PHOTO: Mark Thomas
News11 hours ago

HRH The Princess Royal finds one’s way interpreted by protesting firefighters

Cambridgeshire firefighters stage protest in Huntingdon

Iliran Sinani with the car he was driving and the drugs found in a laundry basket Iliran Sinani with the car he was driving and the drugs found in a laundry basket
Crime14 hours ago

WATCH: Drug dealer caught with £45k worth of cannabis in Ford Transit

Nine bags containing cannabis worth up to £45,000 was discovered in the car

At a ceremony held at Troxy in London, the judges gave Stagecoach East the Gold Award in the Bus and Community category for its work on Behind the Buses. At a ceremony held at Troxy in London, the judges gave Stagecoach East the Gold Award in the Bus and Community category for its work on Behind the Buses.
News14 hours ago

Stagecoach East wins ‘gold’ award for numbers attracted to visit its bus depots

Stagecoach East earlier won the trophy for Excellence in Road Safety, Traffic Management and Enforcement

A strategy to improve buses so that the number of passenger journeys doubles by 2030. This includes a range of improvements, from more electric buses to significant change to how services operate from the current deregulated system. A strategy to improve buses so that the number of passenger journeys doubles by 2030. This includes a range of improvements, from more electric buses to significant change to how services operate from the current deregulated system.
News15 hours ago

Wayne’s exit allows for approval of vital new transport strategy for Cambridgeshire and Peterborough

One aim of the LTCP is to set out future transport options where there is support and a good case...

Cllr Anna Bailey points an angry finger at Mayor Dr Nik Johnson. “He should resign,” she says. Cllr Anna Bailey points an angry finger at Mayor Dr Nik Johnson. “He should resign,” she says.
News16 hours ago

Mayor Nik Johnson threatens ‘formal action’ against Tory council leader for ‘impropriety’ claims

'In your public comments you have cast aspersions against me as a practising doctor' Mayor tells Cllr Bailey.

Bake Off photo: Channel 4 / Mark Bourdillon / Love Productions Bake Off photo: Channel 4 / Mark Bourdillon / Love Productions
News1 day ago

Peterborough teacher is 2023 Great British Bake Off winner

Channel 4 described Matty as the type of baker “who swats up on online patisserie videos before bed

Residents in Terrington St Clement say health and safety has “gone mad” after their local council placed yellow warning tags on gravestones. PHOTO: Terry Harris Residents in Terrington St Clement say health and safety has “gone mad” after their local council placed yellow warning tags on gravestones. PHOTO: Terry Harris
News2 days ago

37 gravestones in Fens village – some brand new – ‘unsafe’ as residents claim health and safety ‘gone mad’

'Who seriously sat down with the H&S team stifling a laugh when they said ‘these leaning stones are a risk''?

King’s College, Cambridge, has started placing solar panels on its iconic 15th century Chapel – despite opposition from local residents and organisations, including Historic England. PHOTO: BavMedia King’s College, Cambridge, has started placing solar panels on its iconic 15th century Chapel – despite opposition from local residents and organisations, including Historic England. PHOTO: BavMedia
News2 days ago

Residents ‘devastated’ as King’s College, Cambridge, puts 492 solar panels on its roof

King’s College, Cambridge, has begun placing solar panels on its iconic 15th century chapel – despite opposition from residents and...

UNISON Eastern regional secretary Tim Roberts said: “The care system would implode without migrant care staff. Demonising these workers will do nothing to solve the social care crisis. UNISON Eastern regional secretary Tim Roberts said: “The care system would implode without migrant care staff. Demonising these workers will do nothing to solve the social care crisis.
News2 days ago

Union demands Government averts adult social care disaster after collapse of Cambridgeshire care home

A visa extension would allow overseas care workers more time to find new employment, says UNISON

Sample of the plans for conversion of Nags Head, Eastrea, into a village shop. Highways official say they not acceptable Sample of the plans for conversion of Nags Head, Eastrea, into a village shop. Highways official say they not acceptable
News2 days ago

Cambridgeshire village shop plans ‘lack clarity’ ‘illegible’ and create ‘confusion’

Whittlesey town council is recommending refusal