Connect with us

News

Enforcement action against Andrews Coaches of Foxton quashed on appeal

Planning Inspectorate rules ‘the enforcement notice is invalid and will be quashed’

Avatar photo

Published

on

The Planning Inspectorate quashed an enforcement notice issued by South Cambridgeshire District Council against Andrews Coaches of Foxton near Cambridge. The enforcement notice was served in September 2021 alleging breaches of planning control.

But D Hartley, the inspector who conducted an appeal, has confirmed, two years later, that “the enforcement notice does not specify with sufficient clarity the alleged breach of planning control.

“It is not open to me to correct the error in accordance with my powers since injustice would be caused were I to do so”.

Advertisements
Pictures

Mr Hartley added: “The enforcement notice is invalid and will be quashed.”

The coach firm is based at 22 Cambridge Road, Foxton, and the council had alleged a material change of use for part of the land which they claimed did not having planning permission for a coach depot including the parking and storage of coaches.

Council wanted coaches removed from land

The council had wanted the removal of all coaches and all items associated with the coach depot and coach storage permanently from part of the land.

South Cambridgeshire District Council also alleged Andrews Coaches had created an area of hardstanding for use as a coach depot on the land.

But boss Andrew Miller appealed to the Planning Inspectorate and has been successful in having the enforcement notice lifted.

Enforcement action against Andrews Coaches of Foxton -begun by South Cambridgeshire District Council - has been quashed on appeal

Enforcement action against Andrews Coaches of Foxton -begun by South Cambridgeshire District Council – has been quashed on appeal

The council had also told him to remove all hardstanding from the area of land in dispute and reseed with grass.

He was given three months to comply, but that period was frozen pending the appeal.

Mr Hartley said there were two grounds for appeal, and he had dealt with them together because of an overlap of issues.

His ruling – published last week – examines all the issues raised by the council and deals with the legalities in depth.

He concludes that “there has not been a material change of use as alleged by the notice”.

Mr Hartley said: “It is theoretically possible that there has been a material change of use through intensification of the coach depot component, but I cannot consider whether that has occurred because there is not sufficient evidence before me.

Advertisements
canopyuk.com in-article

“In this case, I cannot therefore correct the breach of planning control without causing injustice.

“Furthermore, a possible correction of the breach of planning control would cause injustice in so far that the case made by the appellant in respect of some of the grounds of appeal would likely have been very different.”

Not sufficient clarity claim

He added: “The notice also relates to a hardstanding. This appears to be enforced against in its own right. The notice states that the same ‘land hatched blue’ as the alleged material change of use includes unauthorised hardstanding.

“Given my findings relating to the alleged material change of use, I do not find that there is sufficient clarity in the notice in terms of the purpose for which the said hardstanding would be used.

“It is not, for example, clear whether the hardstanding has been used to facilitate a material change of use through intensification of the mixed use on the site.”

Mr Hartley added: “A consideration of the hardstanding area in isolation is not possible as I cannot be certain about the specifics of the use of such hardstanding given my conclusion relating to the alleged material change of use.

“In other words, the consideration of the hardstanding area needs to be considered alongside the use of such land and the breach of planning control is not accurate and so does not provide the certainty needed in this regard.

Breach of planning control not described

“Furthermore, it is not clear whether the hardstanding area has or has not facilitated a material change of the land through intensification. This is a matter that would need to be separately investigated by the council.

“In conclusion, the notice does not describe a breach of planning control that has occurred.

“There has either been no material change of use and no breach, or there has been a different breach which the notice could not be corrected to describe. The outcome is the same either way.

“Furthermore, and for the reasons outlined, I cannot proceed to consider the alleged hardstanding with sufficient clarity and certainty in terms of its use.

“Therefore, and, for these reasons, the appeals succeed.”

 

Facebook

Read More

A snapshot of the horror that awaited RSPCA and council officials when they visited the Wardy Hill near Ely home of Jackie Draper A snapshot of the horror that awaited RSPCA and council officials when they visited the Wardy Hill near Ely home of Jackie Draper
News1 day ago

Greedy Cambridgeshire breeder crams 44 dogs into her house of horrors

Cruel breeder's actions 'deliberate, pre-planned, premeditated and motivated by profit'

News1 day ago

OPINION: We can’t afford another five years of the Conservatives doing Peterborough down

'This is our chance to build a better Britain, and a better Peterborough'

Luton councillor Javeria Hussain has been confirmed as Labour’s choice to fight the forthcoming General Election in NE Cambridgeshire Luton councillor Javeria Hussain has been confirmed as Labour’s choice to fight the forthcoming General Election in NE Cambridgeshire
News1 day ago

Steve Barclay’s fingerprints as a minister ‘are all over this truly terrible administration’ says Labour hopeful

She stood as a Labour MEP candidate for the East of England in 2019

Ian Sollom is the Liberal Democrat Parliamentary candidate for St Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire Ian Sollom is the Liberal Democrat Parliamentary candidate for St Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire
News1 day ago

OPINION: The Conservative party are simply unfit to run our NHS

Patients should be able to see their GP when they need to

The new Wisbech Free school will be run by the Brooke Weston Trust, which also runs the Thomas Clarkson Academy (above), and is expected to be fully operational by 2026. The new Wisbech Free school will be run by the Brooke Weston Trust, which also runs the Thomas Clarkson Academy (above), and is expected to be fully operational by 2026.
News1 day ago

Students spared 40 mile round trip commute after agreement reached to fund Wisbech Free school

The new school will be run by the Brooke Weston Trust

Police and Crime Commissioner Darryl Preston with amnesty weapons at Parkside police station Cambridge (left) and Thorpe Wood police station (right) Police and Crime Commissioner Darryl Preston with amnesty weapons at Parkside police station Cambridge (left) and Thorpe Wood police station (right)
News1 day ago

Swords and machetes among 150 weapons surrendered during Cambridgeshire amnesty

Maximum penalty for an adult carrying a knife is four years in prison

Cllr Javeria Hussain has been a member of Luton Council since 2019 and is portfolio holder for skills and employability. Cllr Javeria Hussain has been a member of Luton Council since 2019 and is portfolio holder for skills and employability.
News2 days ago

Labour selects Luton councillor for NE Cambridgeshire General Election battle

Cllr Hussain is a director of London Luton Airport Ltd

Jesus Green Lock footbridge (above) has reopened, to the delight of residents and Cambridge Beer festival goers. PHOTO: Camcycle Jesus Green Lock footbridge (above) has reopened, to the delight of residents and Cambridge Beer festival goers. PHOTO: Camcycle
News2 days ago

Council gives green light to walk over water as Jesus Green Lock footbridge re-opens

Baits Bite Lock footbridge, Cambridge, will remain closed

MP Jonathan Djanogly (left) with NE Cambs MP Steve Barclay MP Jonathan Djanogly (left) with NE Cambs MP Steve Barclay
News2 days ago

46 word ‘goodbye to Huntingdon’ tweet by MP Jonathan Djanogly 

Selection committee voted 12-9 to reject Mr Djanogly as their candidate

Matthew Warren (right) with (left) Ben Obese-Jecty the Conservative Parliamentary candidate for Huntingdon earlier this year. The candidate had asked to meet with Cambridgeshire Fire and Rescue. Others pictured are area commander Stuart Smith, and ACFO Jon Anderson. Matthew Warren (right) with (left) Ben Obese-Jecty the Conservative Parliamentary candidate for Huntingdon earlier this year. The candidate had asked to meet with Cambridgeshire Fire and Rescue. Others pictured are area commander Stuart Smith, and ACFO Jon Anderson.
News2 days ago

Matthew Warren to become £173,000 a year chief fire officer for Cambridgeshire

As deputy chief executive he earns £150,000 a year