Connect with us

Local Council

Cambridgeshire Indian restaurant wins appeal to build 2 homes in car park

Avatar photo

Published

on

A planning inspector ruled that two large homes can be built in the garden of a former Cambridgeshire pub that is now a successful Indian restaurant.

Three different appeals were submitted by Cordage 28 Ltd after East Cambridgeshire turned down applications to develop the site next to the Crown Inn, 14 Church Street, Fordham CB7 5NJ.

But the Planning Inspectorate has ruled that two 4-bedroom homes can be built next to what is now the Indian Garden restaurant.

The Crown Inn at Fordham was a public house until recently but planning permission was granted for a change of use to an Indian restaurant in February 2021. Now the owners have won the right to build two homes within the car park.

The Crown Inn at Fordham was a public house until recently but planning permission was granted for a change of use to an Indian restaurant in February 2021. Now the owners have won the right to build two homes within the car park.

The Crown Inn was a public house until recently but planning permission was granted for a change of use to a restaurant in February 2021.

David Reed, the inspector who heard the appeal, said the main issues were the effect on the character and appearance of the area, including the effect on the significance of the adjacent Grade II listed building and the Fordham Conservation Area (CA).

He also had to judge whether it would lead to highway safety risks as a result of the restaurant delivery arrangements or insufficient parking spaces leading to on-street parking in the vicinity.

Mr Reed also considered whether the loss of parking spaces would threaten the long-term viability of the restaurant.

The Crown Inn at Fordham was a public house until recently but planning permission was granted for a change of use to an Indian restaurant in February 2021. Now the owners have won the right to build two homes within the car park.

The Crown Inn at Fordham was a public house until recently but planning permission was granted for a change of use to an Indian restaurant in February 2021. Now the owners have won the right to build two homes within the car park.

Advertisements
canopyuk.com in-article

And would the homes provide acceptable living conditions for future residents with regard to access to their dedicated car parking spaces and/or noise and disturbance from the restaurant car park?

In each case a strip of car parking would be retained adjacent to the restaurant.

Other than their layout and detailed house designs, the three schemes raise very similar issues and unless specifically stated otherwise are dealt with together in this decision,” he said.

He pointed out that The Crown Inn was an important public house in the village from the 1760s but obviously without a large car park until the late 20th century.

The Crown Inn at Fordham was a public house until recently but planning permission was granted for a change of use to an Indian restaurant in February 2021. Now the owners have won the right to build two homes within the car park.

The Crown Inn at Fordham was a public house until recently but planning permission was granted for a change of use to an Indian restaurant in February 2021. Now the owners have won the right to build two homes within the car park.

“Contrary to the council’s view, in its village street setting the significance of the listed building would not be diminished by development on the appeal site,” he said.

“Buildings previously lined the site frontage, and the proposals would not block the important view of the gable end when approaching from the west.

“The outbuilding and principal southern elevation would be unaffected.

“Overall, the appreciation and understanding of the building as an historic village roadside inn does not depend on an open setting to the west and would be unaffected by two new dwellings.

“Indeed, the large expanse of empty car park and/or parked cars detract from its setting.”

The Crown Inn at Fordham was a public house until recently but planning permission was granted for a change of use to an Indian restaurant in February 2021. Now the owners have won the right to build two homes within the car park.

The Crown Inn at Fordham was a public house until recently but planning permission was granted for a change of use to an Indian restaurant in February 2021. Now the owners have won the right to build two homes within the car park.

Mr Reed said that in relation to the character and appearance of the Fordham CA more generally “and this section of Church Street in particular, unfortunately no CA appraisal has been prepared and the council’s evidence includes no analysis”.

He said of the schemes before him, the one now approved “would positively enhance the CA and the setting of the listed building.

“It would enhance the character and appearance of the area, would not detract from the significance of the adjacent Grade II listed building and would enhance the Fordham CA”.

Mr Reed said the site forms part of a large car park serving the adjacent restaurant which is not laid out but provides about 20 spaces, maybe more.

Under the proposals 14 marked out spaces would be provided, including one disabled space.

He said the council argued that 44 spaces should be provided for the restaurant to meet the 1 space per 5 m² parking standard set by policies and the shortfall will lead to on-street parking and a danger to highway safety in the vicinity at peak times.

“However, this shortfall is based on the floorspace of the whole building, about 220 m², whereas the floorspace of the ground floor restaurant is just 119 m², suggesting the provision of 24 spaces,” he said.

“In addition, the standard is a maximum figure, not a requirement, allowing a lower level of provision depending on the circumstances.”

There was ample unused capacity in the vicinity with the large open and unregulated car park opposite and long stretches of unrestricted kerbside parking on Church Street.

He said that any overspill on-street parking is thus likely to be limited and infrequent, with inconsiderate on-street parking leading to highway safety issues correspondingly unlikely.

“Contrary to the council’s concerns, the local highway authority is satisfied that highway safety would not be compromised, concluding that the car park would be an adequate size to accommodate the demand from the restaurant and, subject to conditions, the delivery arrangements would be satisfactory,” said Mr Reed.

“For these reasons the proposals would not lead to significant highway safety risks as a result of insufficient parking spaces leading to on-street parking in the vicinity or unsatisfactory delivery arrangements.”

Mr Reed said the council was concerned that the long-term viability of the restaurant could be affected by the loss of car parking.

But he said the provision of 14 spaces would be sufficient to support the use in addition to the alternative parking options in the vicinity.

“It follows that the long-term viability of the use, and therefore the future of the listed building, would not be prejudiced by the loss of car parking,” he said.

“The need for car parking to support any future changes of use can only be speculative but there is no reason to suggest that significantly more off-street parking would be a critical factor in securing an alternative use for the listed building, or indeed use as an alternative community facility.”

He concluded that none of the schemes proposed would have posed significant highway safety risks, affect the long-term viability of the restaurant or provide unacceptable living conditions for future residents.

In the circumstances, he concluded, permission should be given to the scheme allowed.

Mr Reed said the applicant objects to a condition removing permitted development rights for the erection of gates across the site access but this was necessary to ensure access at all times for resident’s cars and restaurant delivery vehicles without the inconvenience and highway safety risks of stopping to open gates.

“A condition to limit restaurant deliveries to outside opening hours is also necessary in the interests of highway safety,” he said.

“Finally, conditions are necessary to ensure any archaeological remains are investigated and biodiversity enhancements are secured to protect the interests concerned.”

 

 

 

 

The Crown Inn at Fordham was a public house until recently but planning permission was granted for a change of use to a restaurant in February 2021. Now the owners have won the right to build two homes within the car park.

 

 

Can you help us?

While you’re here, we are asking, for the first time, for readers to support us financially by taking out a modest subscription.

£2, or £3 or even £5 will help us achieve our goals. It will mean the second year of CambsNews will be livelier, healthier, and much better placed to cover the important issues affecting our everyday lives.

Your subscription simply means we can provide and expand our news FREE to all readers (Read More)

Will you help us? Simply click the link below to make a donation.

Facebook

Read More

News9 hours ago

We need YOUR support to take CambsNews to the next level – here’s how YOU can help

We are asking, for the first time, for readers to support us financially by taking out a modest subscription.

Blake Healy (right) and Zak Wales being arrested. The meat and fish also in the photo had been stolen by Zak Wales. Blake Healy (right) and Zak Wales being arrested. The meat and fish also in the photo had been stolen by Zak Wales.
Crime10 hours ago

Jailing two Cambridge shoplifters ‘will be welcome news to businesses’

'This pair show no regard for walking out of stores with baskets full of stolen items'

Susan Folkes, 68, of Black Horse Drove, Littleport, died after the red Ford Focus she was driving was involved in a crash with two tractors Susan Folkes, 68, of Black Horse Drove, Littleport, died after the red Ford Focus she was driving was involved in a crash with two tractors
News10 hours ago

‘Loyal and kind’ woman killed in crash on the A10 near Littleport

A 40-year-old man from Norfolk was arrested on suspicion of causing death by careless driving

Norwood Road, March, ‘ground breaking’ ceremony for a scheme poised to bring 50 new affordable homes to the heart of March, comprising of all affordable rent properties. Completion on the site, supported by grant funding from Homes England, is expected in November 2025. Norwood Road, March, ‘ground breaking’ ceremony for a scheme poised to bring 50 new affordable homes to the heart of March, comprising of all affordable rent properties. Completion on the site, supported by grant funding from Homes England, is expected in November 2025.
News11 hours ago

Accent’s accelerated charge to reduce housing waiting lists in Cambridgeshire

Accent speaks of its development ambitions for them across Fenland, Huntingdonshire, and Cambridgeshire

Cllr Asim Mahmood and Andrew Pakes Labour Parliamentary candidate, on a visit to the bus depot in Lincoln Road, Peterborough. Cllr Asim Mahmood and Andrew Pakes Labour Parliamentary candidate, on a visit to the bus depot in Lincoln Road, Peterborough.
News13 hours ago

£200,000 finally released to kick start ‘overwhelming’ need for new bus depot for Peterborough

'I am looking forward to working with the Combined Authority to help deliver many of our priorities'

Drug dealer George Bellamy, 24, of Broadway, Yaxley, had heroin, cocaine and £2,290 in cash when he was arrested: a further £3,170 in cash was found in a safe. Drug dealer George Bellamy, 24, of Broadway, Yaxley, had heroin, cocaine and £2,290 in cash when he was arrested: a further £3,170 in cash was found in a safe.
Crime14 hours ago

By George! Drug dealer told cough up £5,000 or face extra time in jail

'Not only has Bellamy got a significant prison sentence, but he must also pay back his ill-gotten gains'

Joy, as she was known to one and all, leaves her husband of 57 years, three children and six grandchildren. Joy, as she was known to one and all, leaves her husband of 57 years, three children and six grandchildren.
News15 hours ago

Family tribute to wife, mum and grandmother, 79, killed in A16 crash near Peterborough

'She wore many different hats during her life including working for the American air force at Mildenhall'

Historic day for Huntingdon as HRH The Princess Royal officially opened the new fire station and Cambs fire and rescue training centre Historic day for Huntingdon as HRH The Princess Royal officially opened the new fire station and Cambs fire and rescue training centre
News16 hours ago

GALLERY: Huntingdon fire station welcomes HRH The Princess Royal

Evlyn, 8, and Keevah, 11 – whose fathers work at the fire station – presented Her Royal Highness with a...

Ernie Almond, who has died aged 80 after a short illness. He spent many happy years as a radio presenter on BBC Three Counties Radio, as one half of the popular “Ern and Vern Show”. Ernie Almond, who has died aged 80 after a short illness. He spent many happy years as a radio presenter on BBC Three Counties Radio, as one half of the popular “Ern and Vern Show”.
News16 hours ago

Radio legend Ernie Almond: ‘A funny modest talented and selfless man with just a hint of mischief’

Ernie Almond joined the Black Cat Radio team from the moment of its FM launch in April 2017

Firefighters stage protest in Huntingdon over reduction in reduction to fire crews PHOTO: Mark Thomas Firefighters stage protest in Huntingdon over reduction in reduction to fire crews PHOTO: Mark Thomas
News1 day ago

HRH The Princess Royal finds one’s way interrupted by protesting firefighters

Cambridgeshire firefighters stage protest in Huntingdon