Connect with us

Local Council

‘Modest scale’ 4 homes for Elm near Wisbech allowed on appeal

Fenland Council planning committee agreed with officers that the housing should be refused.

Avatar photo

Published

on

It has taken a Government planning inspector to appreciate that walking and cycling is an option to get out of your front door by allowing four houses to be built on a site Fenland Council felt was inaccessible.

Local builders Messrs A & S Clarke have won an appeal against the council’s refusal to allow them to build the homes on a one-acre site in Elm near Wisbech.

Mr J Hobson of the Planning Inspectorate, in allowing the appeal, said the main issue was whether the appeal site is an appropriate location for the houses, with regard to the accessibility of the site by “sustainable transport modes”.

The site, off Atkinsons Lane, an adopted highway, is approximately 240m from its junction to the east with the B1101

“Atkinson’s Lane is narrow and has shared facilities for both pedestrians and vehicles, with grass verges either side,” said Mr Hobbs.

“This section of the lane does not accommodate street lighting; however, there is a streetlight over the parking area opposite the appeal site, facing away from the lane.

“Whilst the light is directed away from the lane, there may be some light spill onto the lane itself.”

He said: “This section of Atkinson’s Lane is only used to access a farm and equestrian facilities therefore the number of vehicular movements is low.

Advertisements
canopyuk.com in-article

“Despite the characteristics of the road, due to the low traffic environment it is actively used by dog walkers and horse riders.

“The proposal would lead to the development of up to 4 dwellings.

“As the application subject to this appeal is an outline application, the size of the dwellings is unknown.

“Nonetheless, the number of vehicular journeys along Atkinson’s Lane would increase due to the movements of future residents and services, such as delivery drivers, accessing the properties.

“Regardless, the number of vehicular journeys would still be low given the modest scale of the proposed development.

“It would therefore not lead to the loss of the low traffic environment which encourages walkers, cyclists, and horse riders.”

He added: “Vehicles and people accessing the site along Atkinson’s Lane, would be able to join the road at its junction with Cedar Way which is only a short distance from the appeal site.

“Cedar Way has a footpath and street lighting, and the walk to the centre of the village is short and across relatively flat ground.

“These characteristics would encourage people to use sustainable transport modes, walking and cycling, to access facilities and services in the village.

“Also, as Cedar Way is only a short distance from the appeal site, the chances of conflict between vehicles and other road users is significantly reduced.

“Consequently, the appeal site is an appropriate location for the proposed development having regard to the accessibility of the site by sustainable transport modes.”

Elm parish council had argued that Atkinsons Lane regularly floods “due to surface water running off the development currently under construction on the south side of the Lane.

“Further development in the area would increase the risk of flooding for existing neighbouring properties.

“The proposed site is agricultural farmland, if development were approved it would set a precedent and could lead to further applications being submitted on adjacent land.

“Atkinsons Lane is a single lane track; it is totally unsuitable for use as an access route to the proposed site.”

The developers promised that the shared access road had been designed so that Fenland Council refuse lorries can enter/turn within the site for collection of bins from the four new homes.

They argued the site would be “a logical infill”.

Fenland Council planning committee agreed with officers that the housing should be refused.

A report to the committee noted that “whilst strong representations have been received both objecting to and supporting the development, it is considered that on balance, any further residential development served off Atkinsons Lane would fail to accord with the principles of sustainable development”.

Planning officers argued that “the proposal would make a limited contribution to local housing need and the occupiers of the proposed new dwellings would be reliant upon the private motor car to access local facilities and services with the associated lack of appropriate infrastructure”.

The developers had claimed that although Atkinsons Lane is narrow being between 2.4m and 2.8m in width “it has adequate width to accommodate refuse lorries, with the layout and access design within the site providing a turning space to allow the refuse vehicle to safely turn and this is accepted by the council’s environmental services officers”.

“Atkinsons Lane, Elm is a single lane track; it is totally unsuitable for use as an access route to the proposed site” was the view of the parish council. The photo of a refuse lorry using the lane was provided to Fenland Council in November 21, and published on their planning portal.

“Atkinsons Lane, Elm is a single lane track; it is totally unsuitable for use as an access route to the proposed site” was the view of the parish council. The photo of a refuse lorry using the lane was provided to Fenland Council in November 21, and published on their planning portal.

The site backs onto new residential development at The Oaks to the east, existing residential development fronting Begdale Road to the north, and a complex of farm buildings to the south.

Although the county council and environmental services raised no objection, the planning committee felt it should still be refused “on the principles of enabling sustainable forms of development”.

The appeal heard that all four homes are to be self-build, with the plots sold off separately.

The inspector said: “There is no substantive evidence that the appellant desires to develop the rest of the field and all future proposals would be assessed on their own planning merit.

“This decision is without prejudice to any future applications on adjoining land.”

He also noted: “The nature of the road would limit the speed of moving vehicles, also the chance of conflict is low considering vehicles could access Cedar Way and The Oaks and therefore would only have to use a short section of Atkinson’s Lane.

“Vehicles would therefore be able to manoeuvre safely along the road.

“Moreover, the council do not consider that the proposed development would lead to any highway safety concerns.”

He said: “There is no substantive evidence before me that the appeal site or Atkinson’s Lane floods.

“The proposed development should not increase flooding elsewhere including properties which are sited on lower ground.”

“The issue of the effect of the proposed development on property values has also been raised.

“It is a well-founded principle that the planning system does not exist to protect private interests such as value of land or property.”

A condition requiring the on-site parking and turning area to be laid out prior to first occupation was necessary, said the inspector, “to ensure that appropriate servicing facilities are provided and in the interest of highway safety”.

 

Can you help us?

While you’re here, we are asking, for the first time, for readers to support us financially by taking out a modest subscription.

£2, or £3 or even £5 will help us achieve our goals. It will mean the second year of CambsNews will be livelier, healthier, and much better placed to cover the important issues affecting our everyday lives.

Your subscription simply means we can provide and expand our news FREE to all readers (Read More)

Will you help us? Simply click the link below to make a donation.

Facebook

Read More

Ben and Sarah Dodkin, accompanied by their children Finley, Arthur, and Harrison, were among special guests invited to the Princess of Wales Christmas concert. The family’s efforts to raise awareness of Batten’s Disease prompted the VIP invite Ben and Sarah Dodkin, accompanied by their children Finley, Arthur, and Harrison, were among special guests invited to the Princess of Wales Christmas concert. The family’s efforts to raise awareness of Batten’s Disease prompted the VIP invite
News17 mins ago

Princess of Wales Christmas concert ‘truly a unique and very special memory maker’

Both Finley and Harrison, the Dodkin’s sons, are registered blind due to this rare neurological disease

Cllr Alex Bulat “never thought or planned to be a local politician”. Cllr Alex Bulat “never thought or planned to be a local politician”.
News21 hours ago

Romanian born councillor hopes to be Labour’s choice to be Huntingdon MP

'I moved to the UK from Romania in 2012; I was 18 years old'

Hansel and Gretel is at Cambridge Junction until New Year’s Eve Hansel and Gretel is at Cambridge Junction until New Year’s Eve
News23 hours ago

REVIEW: Brilliant Hansel and Gretel children’s show ‘an absolute scream for adults’

This is a fun, fast-paced show with plenty of audience participation

One of the failures of Neale-Wade, says Ofsted, is for ‘behaviour and attitudes” which inspectors observed during their two-day inspection on October 31 and November 1, 2023. One of the failures of Neale-Wade, says Ofsted, is for ‘behaviour and attitudes” which inspectors observed during their two-day inspection on October 31 and November 1, 2023.
News23 hours ago

Ofsted again finds Neale-Wade Academy March ‘requires improvement’

Critical Ofsted report has some glimmers of hope

Investments include a series of system upgrades as well as five new rigid trucks and ten new fork lifts Investments include a series of system upgrades as well as five new rigid trucks and ten new fork lifts
Business1 day ago

£1m investment to kick start New Year for Masters of Stretham near Ely

Cracking start to 2024 for Cambridgeshire logistics company

Kyle Spiers jailed Kyle Spiers jailed
Crime1 day ago

Paedophile voyeur’s ‘incredible arrogance and disregard for the law’

A mobile phone was seized which contained footage Spires had filmed of a child covertly

Christmas party venue at Lode – December 7 will be decision day for licensing by East Cambridgeshire District Council Christmas party venue at Lode – December 7 will be decision day for licensing by East Cambridgeshire District Council
News1 day ago

Lodestar site near Cambridge wins approval for large scale Christmas parties  

The licence approved for the site allows for up to 28 events

Stefan Hague, 33, of Hyde, Greater Manchester, barged through the door at the victim’s Peterborough home and refused to leave. Stefan Hague, 33, of Hyde, Greater Manchester, barged through the door at the victim’s Peterborough home and refused to leave.
Crime2 days ago

Rapist still covered in Peterborough victim’s blood as police arrived to arrest him

Detective Sergeant Matt Lauch said: “Hague is an extremely dangerous individual"

Simon Lattore called police and claimed he’d left a bomb in the disabled toilets of a Huntingdon pub Simon Lattore called police and claimed he’d left a bomb in the disabled toilets of a Huntingdon pub
Crime2 days ago

AUDIO: Hoaxer’s 999 call to warn police bomb would ‘go off’ in Huntingdon pub

Listen to the 999 call of Huntingdon bomb hoaxer

Stalker Philip Robinson who crept into a woman’s bedroom while she was sleeping has been jailed. Stalker Philip Robinson who crept into a woman’s bedroom while she was sleeping has been jailed.
Crime2 days ago

‘Despicable’ stalker crept into victim’s home and entered her bedroom

Cambridgeshire police released this custody photo of stalker Phillip Robinson