Connect with us

News

Planning inspector rules against 10 gypsy/traveller pitches near Wilburton, Ely

A site for 10 gypsy/traveller pitches on land north of Pools Road, Wilburton, Ely, has been refused on appeal

Avatar photo

Published

on

A Cambridgeshire family has lost its battle with a district council to provide 10 gypsy/traveller pitches – each with a static and touring caravan. The Planning Inspectorate dismissed an appeal by A Buckley who appealed against a decision by East Cambridgeshire District Council.

Planning inspector Jonathan Price ruled against Mr Buckley despite agreeing the site “would provide a settled and secure base for the ten growing households”.

The site is on land north of Pools Road, Wilburton, Ely, and Mr Price heard evidence from both the council and Mr Buckley and his representatives at a public inquiry in Ely on August

Mr Price concluded: “The proposal will create a significant visual disturbance in the fen landscape that would be detrimental to the overall character of the area.”

Advertisements
Pictures
Advertisement

The inspector said it was agreed by all parties that East Cambridgeshire’s accommodation assessment for gypsy and traveller housing was out of date.

But he said the main issues were the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the area, and whether the site would provide safe access, and be within a reasonable distance of regularly required services and facilities

The appeal site is a rectangular parcel of land to the south of Witchford.

Advertisement

Mr Price said it is laid mainly to grass and has been sub-divided into 10 paddocks; five either side of an access track running perpendicularly from a centrally located entrance from Pools Road.

Among issues raised, he said that although the vegetation provides some degree of visual enclosure, the proposed pitches would run deep into land that rises gently.

“This proposal would have a comparatively greater impact than existing traveller sites in the locality,” he said.

“These are mainly on shallower plots that run along the public highway, from where the visual impact would mainly be confined.

Advertisement

“This proposal would be along a stretch of road lacking traveller sites and much development at all.

“In such a context, the harm to the landscape from a deep incursion of ten caravan pitches would be particularly pronounced.

“The rising land would reduce the effectiveness of the front hedging in screening the pitches towards the rear of the site. Views from the road and through the vegetation, particularly during winter months, would be of development extending deep into the open landscape, accentuating the adverse visual impacts of the caravans and associated features.

“The proposal would have a particularly harmful effect on views from the public right of way running at an elevated height alongside the rear site boundary.

Advertisements
canopyuk.com in-article
Advertisement

“From here, as well as approaching from the north along Grunty Fen Road, the ten pitches and their contents would be very prominent. The existing vegetation would not fully screen the pitches, but the hedging around the site might be maintained to soften views.

“The caravan pitches would nevertheless comprise a discordant feature within a surrounding undeveloped area of horse pastures, tree planting and farm land.”

He felt the proposal overall “would have a significant adverse impact on the countryside”.

The inspector agreed that meeting a need for gypsy and traveller accommodation “requires an inevitable degree of harm to the character and appearance of the rural landscape.

Advertisement

“However, due to the relatively attractive and unspoilt nature of the countryside along this section of Pools Road, the scale and depth of the incursion into this and the public views available from both the front and rear of the site, the degree of harm attracts substantial weight”.

Mr Price assessed the personal circumstances of the applicant and his family who “are currently living in sites dispersed around the county and in situations which are often less secure, overcrowded and where there is not the support of close family members that this proposal would provide.

“These personal circumstances also weigh significantly in favour of the proposal. In considering these, I have borne in mind Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights as this relates to a respect for private and family life.

“I have considered this in regard to the cultural aspects of gypsy and traveller life and the benefits of this proposal in bringing together a currently dispersed extended family.

Advertisement

“In this context, the best interests of the children involved has been my primary consideration. It is forefront in my mind that the mutual family support provided through a collective and settled base could be particularly beneficial towards meeting the health, welfare and educational needs of the children involved.

“However, these combined benefits are insufficient to outweigh the development plan conflict and associated adverse impacts. This is particularly given the substantial degree of harm found to the character and appearance of the countryside and the weight given to this.”

With the lack of an up-to-date five-year supply of deliverable traveller sites, the inspector considered the “significant” issue of granting temporary permission.

“However, this would not materially alter the balance of considerations, as the harm found to the character and appearance of the countryside would remain substantial and the overall benefits, in not providing a permanent settled base, would be less,” he said.

Advertisement

“Therefore, permission on a temporary basis would not be appropriate and, for the reasons given, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.”

 

Facebook

Read More

Police briefing ahead of arrests Police briefing ahead of arrests
News12 hours ago

Cambridge: Children arrested for robbery, theft, harassment, threats to kill and knife crime

Arrests made in Abbey ward and Cherry Hinton

Cllr Shepherd and Chief Supt Paul French Cllr Shepherd and Chief Supt Paul French
News12 hours ago

OPINION: Cyclists get a ‘wake up’ reminder – could it happen in Cambridgeshire?

Tannoy system piloted by NE Lincolnshire Council

CA-business-award-student-winners-with-Michael-Bates-Derrick-Holmes-Brian-Kett-and-Peter-Dennis-of-Wisbech-BPMC CA-business-award-student-winners-with-Michael-Bates-Derrick-Holmes-Brian-Kett-and-Peter-Dennis-of-Wisbech-BPMC
News13 hours ago

End of year achievements celebrated at Thomas Clarkson Academy, Wisbech

Awards presented across all departments of the academy

(left) Imogen Grant, former student at Stephen Perse Cambridge and lightweight world champion rower and (right) Bethany Shriever, former teaching assistant at Dame Bradbury’s Junior School and BMX gold medallist. Photo credit: Stephen Perse Cambridge (left) Imogen Grant, former student at Stephen Perse Cambridge and lightweight world champion rower and (right) Bethany Shriever, former teaching assistant at Dame Bradbury’s Junior School and BMX gold medallist. Photo credit: Stephen Perse Cambridge
News14 hours ago

Stephen Perse Cambridge schools cheer on their Olympic hopefuls

'Great role models who continue to inspire our students'

Horsefair car park. Town Centre, Wisbech Tuesday 23 July 2024. Picture by Terry Harris Horsefair car park. Town Centre, Wisbech Tuesday 23 July 2024. Picture by Terry Harris
News20 hours ago

Horsefair Wisbech 35,000 sq ft discount store and new car park ‘will boost footfall’

NewRiver offer massive vote of confidence in Wisbech

Trio of Cambs Lib Dem MPs (from left) Ian Sollom, the new MP for St Neots & Mid Cambridgeshire, MP for South Cambridgeshire, Pippa Heylings and Charlotte Cane, MP for Ely & East Cambridgeshire Trio of Cambs Lib Dem MPs (from left) Ian Sollom, the new MP for St Neots & Mid Cambridgeshire, MP for South Cambridgeshire, Pippa Heylings and Charlotte Cane, MP for Ely & East Cambridgeshire
News22 hours ago

Cambridgeshire MPs vote for action on sewage dumping, cost of living and NHS in King’s Speech

Cambridgeshire Lib Dem MPs challenge on key issues

Dr Nick Valley – part of his ‘memory bank’ of photographs from a long and distinguished career, many of them spent serving the people of March, Cambridgeshire Dr Nick Valley – part of his ‘memory bank’ of photographs from a long and distinguished career, many of them spent serving the people of March, Cambridgeshire
News23 hours ago

‘Thank you all from bottom of my heart for all your loyalty and support and I will not forget you’

I have tried my best to follow Elaine Stutard's legacy

Five Dances, choreographed by Arielle Smith, is a modern ballet with a large cast of men and women dressed identically Five Dances, choreographed by Arielle Smith, is a modern ballet with a large cast of men and women dressed identically
News24 hours ago

London City Ballet ‘fast, vibrant, inspiring’ at Cambridge Arts Theatre

Classical and contemporary ballet with the freshest possible edge

24 complaints made about Peterborough City councillors since February. PHOTO: Terry Harris 24 complaints made about Peterborough City councillors since February. PHOTO: Terry Harris
News1 day ago

24 conduct complaints made about Peterborough city councillors in just 6 months

One complaint relates to postal vote handling

Workers at Asda Wisbech are angry over a litany of issues Workers at Asda Wisbech are angry over a litany of issues
News2 days ago

Asda workers at Wisbech strike over ‘cuts in hours, bullying management and poor training’

Asda rejects the claims made by the union