Connect with us

Your Views

NIGEL PAULEY: BBC local radio and TV cuts should concern us

Avatar photo

Published

on

by Nigel Pauley

Liz Truss broke her silence on the collapse of the pound by doing the round of local BBC Radio stations.

There was much patronising raising of eyebrows from the snooty London-based political journalists, who felt *they* should get the big chat firsts.

But, if, she thought it was going to be a gentle early morning jog in the park, our new Prime Minister was very soon brought down to earth with a thump.

Local radio presenters showed no mercy as they demolished her trite sound bites and refusal to answer a straight question.

Her eight early morning radio interviews made headlines and dominated social media – for all the wrong reasons.

We may not have realised it then but what we were witnessing was the beginning of the end of Truss’ tenure at Number 10.

Those car crash interviews with Radio Leeds, Norfolk, Kent and Teeside were heard by many more millions than normally tune in.

Columnist Nigel Pauley says the BBC “has lost touch with their core audience and shed countless presenters who did not fit the safe but dull template”.

If ever there was proof that BBC local radio could still pack a punch this, was it.

So, what did the BBC executives do? 

Surely, they would recognise what gems these radio stations were and pour money and resources into them?

Well, no, quite the opposite.

Within weeks they were announcing swingeing cuts to local radio stations, across the UK.

Many, it was claimed by the Guardian’s media editor Jim Waterson, would see just a breakfast show and lunchtime show of “local content.”

BBC officials have since denied this – insisting that 6am-2pm local output would remain – though it does not bode well for the other 16 hours.

Locally we are already coming to terms with losing the dedicated BBC Look East (West) bulletins from Cambridge.

Now BBC Radio Cambs is also threatened – the home of Chris Mann, Jeremy Sallis, Dotty McLeod, and Louise Hulland.

Already we have seen the rapid demise of local newspapers from serious sources of local news into trite purveyors of clickbait content with a more national appeal.

I do spare the excellent Cambridge Independent from that criticism. We really should cherish this weekly from the Iliffe family stable.

Ironically, it was the BBC’s huge investment into the digital content which is blamed by many in the media for hastening the demise of local newspapers who could not compete with the Beeb’s deep pockets.

To lessen their guilt about the devastation they had unwittingly caused, the BBC invested in a tranche of Local Democracy Reporters across the country – we have two in Cambs – covering politics and providing content for local news outlets.

Now, in the dog-eat-dog world of the media, it is the local BBC radio stations themselves under threat.

Added to that the independent radio stations have gone all global – removing local content in favour of national content.

Advertisements
canopyuk.com in-article

Of course, it makes business sense too bean counters – but it short changes us, the listeners.

You might ask, why should we bother? The BBC is having to make cuts and the local radio stations just do not attract the listening figures anymore.

It is their priority to give us best value for our £159 licence fee.

But, as my friend and former BBC Radio Cambridgeshire presenter Paul Stainton pointed out, executives have been draining all life from the stations.

They have lost touch with their core audience and shed countless presenters who did not fit the safe but dull template.

It matters because we need local programmes with the time to devote to big local issues – like the Stagecoach bus cuts, Cambridge congestion charge plan and the problems caused by over-development on our precious water resources.

We need local politicians to be held to account. 

We need the mayor of Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Dr Nik Johnson to explain why he has made decisions.

We need council leaders to be quizzed on decisions they make which affect all of us.

Having been on the end of a grilling from the brilliant Ben Schofield of Look East I know that it is not something you enjoy.

However, like all BBC reporters and presenters I have had dealings with, Ben, Dotty, Chris et al, are scrupulously fair. If a little firm!

Already we have seen local newspapers stopping having dedicated reporters covering local politics.

Without this scrutiny we lose transparency – we will be fed bland press releases from the local authority comms teams, printed word for word without question.

Without this scrutiny, unscrupulous politicians will be using Twitter and other social media platforms, to peddle even more half-truths and fabrications than some of them do now.

That is why it is so important for the BBC to have a strong local presence.

My solution would be for the BBC to get back to its roots. To stop thinking big and get back to thinking smaller.

Allow presenters to display more of their personality – and to go off piste rather than stick to a rigid template.

Recognise that listeners may be older – than BBC executives would wish – or working from home.

Set play lists to reflect the more mature musical tastes. Cut a lot of the floss and stick to local issues affecting listeners and get as many local voices on air as possible.

People have pride in the place they live. The BBC should reflect that pride and its radio station should be proud to deliver quality output centring on local issues.

But most importantly of all the BBC should be investing more in local radio stations – not cutting them and giving us less content from the places where we live!

EDITOR’S NOTE: Nigel Pauley is an occasional columnist for CambsNewsOnline

Facebook

Read More

East Cambs council leader Anna Bailey (left) faced questions at this week’s council meeting from Cllr Mike Goodearl (right) about bus cuts affecting Littleport and from Cllr Lucius Vellacott requesting bus services to Wicken. East Cambs council leader Anna Bailey (left) faced questions at this week’s council meeting from Cllr Mike Goodearl (right) about bus cuts affecting Littleport and from Cllr Lucius Vellacott requesting bus services to Wicken.
News16 mins ago

Residents fury as Stagecoach axe off-peak services from Littleport to Ely

Buses also featured in a question to the leader from Soham councillor Lucius Vellacott

David Cross, of South Brink, Wisbech was last seen on CCTV at 11.24pm on January 31 in the passageway by Nene Terrace, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire David Cross, of South Brink, Wisbech was last seen on CCTV at 11.24pm on January 31 in the passageway by Nene Terrace, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire
News2 hours ago

Fears grow missing Wisbech man ‘may have come to harm’

DI Rich Stott said: 'We are extremely concerned about David’s whereabouts'

South Cambridgeshire District Council’s Lead Cabinet Member for Resources, Cllr John Williams, said: “Our four-day week trial is about improving the consistency of services to residents and businesses – by helping us attract and keep hold of talented staff in a hugely competitive job market.” South Cambridgeshire District Council’s Lead Cabinet Member for Resources, Cllr John Williams, said: “Our four-day week trial is about improving the consistency of services to residents and businesses – by helping us attract and keep hold of talented staff in a hugely competitive job market.”
News4 hours ago

South Cambridgeshire council basks in £434,000 of savings following 4-day week trial

'The Bennett Institute noted however that not a single area of performance fell to a concerning level during the trial'

Passing sentence, Judge Mark Bishop said Nathan Lovell (above) posed a “significant risk” to children and there was an unpredictability to his future behaviour Passing sentence, Judge Mark Bishop said Nathan Lovell (above) posed a “significant risk” to children and there was an unpredictability to his future behaviour
Crime4 hours ago

15 years jail for Wisbech paedophile who targeted victims ‘in the most horrific of ways’

Nathan Lovell, of Opportune Road, Wisbech, was charged with 18 counts in total

Claire Coutinho, Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero (right), agreed a £450m incinerator for Wisbech (outline drawing above) yesterday but today it was withdrawn for “clarification” of her decision. Claire Coutinho, Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero (right), agreed a £450m incinerator for Wisbech (outline drawing above) yesterday but today it was withdrawn for “clarification” of her decision.
News17 hours ago

Go ahead for £450m Wisbech incinerator pulled for ‘clarification’

Fenland Council is expected to pass a motion on Monday that includes inviting Claire Coutinho to visit Fenland

2019: MP Steve Barclay visits Algores Way, Wisbech, to highlight his campaign to stop a mega incinerator being built there. As we learnt yesterday, the campaign failed. 2019: MP Steve Barclay visits Algores Way, Wisbech, to highlight his campaign to stop a mega incinerator being built there. As we learnt yesterday, the campaign failed.
News1 day ago

EXCLUSIVE: Tories in turmoil after Government approves mega incinerator for Wisbech

These are extraordinary times in Fenland

News2 days ago

Tory councillor warns of ‘dark day for Wisbech’ after MP Steve Barclay fails to halt Wisbech incinerator

Tory councillor 'ashamed that the Government felt this was the right result'

Cllr Keith Prentice is yet to publicly give reasons for his switch to the Independents, but it will be another blow for the Conservatives ahead of a crucial General Election Cllr Keith Prentice is yet to publicly give reasons for his switch to the Independents, but it will be another blow for the Conservatives ahead of a crucial General Election
News2 days ago

What another one! Cllr Keith Prentice quits Tory group on Cambridgeshire County Council

Cllr Prentice is yet to publicly give reasons for his switch

WisWIN took their protest to Parliament and to meet MP Steve Barclay WisWIN took their protest to Parliament and to meet MP Steve Barclay
News2 days ago

BREAKING: Government ‘green light’ for £300m Wisbech energy from waste incinerator

Thousands have protested against the incinerator, not least NE Cambs MP Steve Barclay

Cllr Steve Count, challenging the council’s budget proposals across a swathe of issues, homed in on the voucher scheme during a meeting of the strategy and resources committee. Cllr Steve Count, challenging the council’s budget proposals across a swathe of issues, homed in on the voucher scheme during a meeting of the strategy and resources committee.
News2 days ago

Cambridgeshire County Council opposition Tory leader questions holiday food vouchers for needy families

' I do think that there's a certain amount of responsibility for parents having their own children’